Midwives, Medics, and Professional Identity

Grumpy Midwife is still obsessing with issues of professional identity. She has concluded that, like patriotism, a strong professional identify and pride in that identity is a good thing – but only in moderation and only when the end justifies the means.

Recent research conducted by the General Medical Council amongst doctors in training revealed that over 13% had experienced bullying and nearly 1 in 5 had witnessed somebody else being bullied in the workplace (which suggests that being bullied is under-reported). The same survey concluded that 26.5% of the 50,000 respondents had been subjected to “undermining behaviour” from a senior colleague, undermining behaviour being defined as “persistent and deliberate belittling or humiliation” that eroded “professional confidence or self-esteem”. So far, so worrying – but now it gets personal.

Trainees in obstetrics and gynaecology are more likely than any other speciality to report bullying or undermining. And the perpetrators of such behaviour? First consultants, and second “nurses and midwives” – by which we mean midwives since there are virtually no nurses in obstetrics and nurses in gynaecology now seem to be lumped in with surgery and, in any case, seem far too harassed and busy and nice to waste time and energy belittling anybody. Yes, midwives are officially the Bitches of Birthing.

Incidentally, the nearest rivals for the toxic distinction of Nastiest Speciality is pathology. Isn’t that interesting? Obs and gynae is probably the most visible of specialities, with women and families witnessing almost everything we say and do (contrary to popular belief amongst staff, labour ward doors are not soundproof) – whilst pathology is arguably the most invisible (GM knows virtually nothing about working in pathology but imagines a tense and silent lab full of microscopes and anxious people in white coats being constantly interrupted by phone calls from clinicians too impatient to wait for results on the intranet).

So what is it about midwives? GM was recently invited to attend a talk on unacceptable behaviour on the labour ward, delivered by an obstetrician tasked with addressing this issue in maternity units. (The occasion was a Deanery educational event attended by around 100 obstetricians. And three midwives. GM is nothing if not brave.) The speaker (a charming woman of around GM’s vintage) ran down a list of factors that may contribute to unpleasantness in maternity care: stress, shifts, demanding training, risk of litigation, traditional attitudes, lots of female and overseas doctors – and midwives; “midwives are [palpable pause and carefully choice of words] not like nurses“. Cue nervous laughter around the auditorium.

Not like nurses? Meaning… Autonomous practitioners fully accountable for the care of mother and baby throughout normal pregnancy, labour and the postnatal period (Midwives’ Rules, 2012)? With continuing responsibility even when obstetricians are involved to provide “holistic support, maximising continuity of carer and promoting … normal physiological processes” (Safer Childbirth, 2007)? Confident professionals with a long and honourable history? That’s good, surely? Well, not if “autonomous” = insular, “holistic support” = colluding and obstructive, “promoting normality” = blinkered and short-sighted, and “confident” = bullying and belittling.

This isn’t a new or isolated issue. Our Code of Conduct (NMC, 2012) stipulates that midwives “work cooperatively within teams and respect the skills, expertise and contributions of … colleagues”; very similar words to those used in the GMC’s Good Medical Practice guide (2013). Meanwhile, the International Confederation of Midwives in a position statement makes clear that autonomy does not mean working “alone or in isolation from the woman or colleagues” – and this warning brings us back to what really matters in this whole sorry mess.

A strong professional identity – yes – so long as we remember what that identity is and for whose benefit. Midwife = “with woman”; “with woman” not to feed our professional ego but sensitively, skilfully, humbly with each woman. If we place women genuinely at the centre of care there would be no room for bossing or bullying or belittling, just calm professional conversations to plan the best possible care for each and every mother and baby.

Well, that’s Grumpy Midwife’s theory anyway.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s